Clear Review has joined Advanced - Discover our full suite of powerful and innovative people management solutions

Find out more
Back to Overview

Measuring Performance Management Effectiveness

Measure performance management

Subscribe to our newsletter for inspiration, ideas and updates on the latest in performance management.

How Do You Mea­sure the Effec­tive­ness of Your Per­for­mance Man­age­ment Processes?

Below, we explore how to effec­tive­ly imple­ment per­for­mance mea­sure­ment to keep your com­pa­ny and your employ­ees on track.

Organ­i­sa­tions invest a sig­nif­i­cant amount of time (and there­fore mon­ey) in per­for­mance man­age­ment activ­i­ties. Indeed, before their per­for­mance man­age­ment revamp, Deloitte cal­cu­lat­ed their 65,000 employ­ees were spend­ing a total of 2 mil­lion hours a year com­plet­ing forms, hold­ing meet­ings and assign­ing and analysing rat­ings.

CEB found man­agers spent an aver­age of 210 hours per year on per­for­mance man­age­ment, find­ing that a com­pa­ny of 10,000 peo­ple spent $35 mil­lion a year on per­for­mance reviews alone. Yet so many of us — man­agers and employ­ees alike — are dis­sat­is­fied with the qual­i­ty and effec­tive­ness of our per­for­mance man­age­ment systems.

Does this sound all too famil­iar? If so, it’s time you took action and began mea­sur­ing the effec­tive­ness of your per­for­mance man­age­ment system. 

Below, we out­line five steps that will have you on the road to mea­sur­ing per­for­mance in a mean­ing­ful way.

Step 1 — Do Your Research and Bench­mark Best Practice

If you are going to assess the qual­i­ty of your per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem objec­tive­ly, an impor­tant first step is to under­stand what​”excel­lent” looks like for your business.

Spend some time read­ing the lat­est research into per­for­mance man­age­ment trends and best prac­tice. Look at some case stud­ies of organ­i­sa­tions who have suc­ceed­ed after revi­tal­is­ing their per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem. To help with this, we’ve cre­at­ed a free eBook on effec­tive per­for­mance man­age­ment. The book sum­maris­es a wide vari­ety of research and case stud­ies into an eas­i­ly digestible guide.

Want to see how our Performance Management Software works?

Step 2 — Be Clear on Your Organisation’s Goals for Per­for­mance Management

A num­ber of guid­ing prin­ci­ples have come to light in recent research into per­for­mance man­age­ment — such as the impor­tance of hav­ing reg­u­lar future-focused​“check-ins”, giv­ing fre­quent feed­back and decou­pling per­for­mance mea­sure­ment from devel­op­men­tal per­for­mance dis­cus­sions. But how effec­tive your per­for­mance man­age­ment process is will ulti­mate­ly depend on what you are look­ing to get from it. 

For this rea­son, it’s essen­tial to be 100% clear on what your organisation’s goals for per­for­mance man­age­ment are. This is some­thing that should be dis­cussed and agreed with your senior leadership.

A sur­vey con­duct­ed by eRe­ward in 2014 found the most com­mon goals for per­for­mance man­age­ment were:

  • to improve organ­i­sa­tion­al performance

  • to align indi­vid­ual and organ­i­sa­tion­al objectives

  • to devel­op a per­for­mance culture

  • to improve indi­vid­ual performance

  • to align indi­vid­ual behav­iour to organ­i­sa­tion­al values

  • to pro­vide the basis for per­son­al development

  • to inform per­for­mance pay decisions

Step 3 — How to Mea­sure Organ­i­sa­tion­al Per­for­mance: Estab­lish­ing Your Suc­cess Measures

Once you are clear of the goals of your per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem, the next step is to estab­lish what suc­cess should look like for each one. Here are some suc­cess mea­sures for a selec­tion of the com­mon per­for­mance man­age­ment goals above. These show you how to mea­sure the effec­tive­ness of your sys­tem against your per­for­mance man­age­ment goals:

Per­for­mance Man­age­ment Goal

Exam­ple Suc­cess Measures

Improve organ­i­sa­tion­al / team performance

  • Increase in prof­itabil­i­ty of organ­i­sa­tion / teams
  • Growth in rev­enue or oth­er mea­sures such as cus­tomer satisfaction

Improve indi­vid­ual performance

  • Qual­i­ty and fre­quen­cy of employ­ee-man­ag­er per­for­mance conversations
  • Per­cent­age of employ­ees with objec­tives set
  • Qual­i­ty of objectives
  • Per­cent­age of high and low per­form­ers in the organisation

Encour­age per­for­mance development

  • Amount of per­son­al devel­op­ment activ­i­ty undertaken
  • Fre­quen­cy and qual­i­ty of feed­back given

Increase employ­ee moti­va­tion and engagement

  • Employ­ee engage­ment sur­vey results
  • Impact of per­for­mance reviews on employ­ee moti­va­tion levels
  • Employ­ee turnover rates

Inform per­for­mance pay decisions

  • Abil­i­ty of man­agers to dif­fer­en­ti­ate per­for­mance for pay purposes
  • Sat­is­fac­tion lev­els / per­ceived fair­ness of per­­for­­mance-relat­ed pay awards

In addi­tion to agree­ing on suc­cess mea­sures relat­ed to spe­cif­ic per­for­mance goals, it is impor­tant to define some mea­sures for your per­for­mance man­age­ment process­es (i.e. the actu­al mechan­ics). You’ll want to know how easy your employ­ees and man­agers find the process­es and tools they use, how time-con­­­sum­ing they are, how well they are imple­ment­ed, what pro­por­tion of peo­ple are fol­low­ing the process­es and whether peo­ple are demon­strat­ing the nec­es­sary per­for­mance man­age­ment skills.

Step 4 — Eval­u­a­tion of your per­for­mance man­age­ment system

Once you have estab­lished your suc­cess mea­sures, it’s time to start col­lat­ing data and evaluating. 

To tru­ly know how effec­tive your per­for­mance man­age­ment is — and to under­stand how to improve it — you will need a com­bi­na­tion of both qual­i­ta­tive and quan­ti­ta­tive data. Look­ing at quan­ti­ta­tive fig­ures such as com­pa­ny or team prof­itabil­i­ty or employ­ee engage­ment lev­els in iso­la­tion will not help you to under­stand the direct impact per­for­mance man­age­ment had on them — oth­er fac­tors will also be at play. Meth­ods of get­ting use­ful qual­i­ta­tive and quan­ti­ta­tive per­for­mance man­age­ment data include:

  • Car­ry­ing out a ded­i­cat­ed sur­vey of a selec­tion of employ­ees and man­agers on their views and expe­ri­ences of the per­for­mance man­age­ment process and tools and how they have con­tributed to achiev­ing the desired goals

  • Ask­ing spe­cif­ic ques­tions relat­ing to per­for­mance man­age­ment in your exist­ing employ­ee atti­tude surveys

  • Con­duct­ing inter­views with a sam­ple of employ­ees and man­agers about their expe­ri­ences of per­for­mance management

  • Focus groups

  • Extract­ing data and reports from your online per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem (if you have one)

  • Review­ing a sam­ple of objec­tives and per­son­al devel­op­ment plans for quality.

Step 5 — Take Action on the Results

Once you’ve analysed the results, you should have a clear idea of how effec­tive your per­for­mance man­age­ment process­es are and which aspects could be improved. If the results are not as good as you had hoped, don’t be dis­heart­ened as you are not alone. A 2014 study found only 8% of com­pa­nies report­ed that their per­for­mance man­age­ment process dri­ves high lev­els of val­ue. More recent­ly, two-thirds of organ­i­sa­tions sug­gest­ed their per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem was inef­fec­tive. There’s def­i­nite­ly room for improvement. 

The key to improv­ing your per­for­mance man­age­ment is to involve a vari­ety of senior man­agers, man­agers and employ­ees in dis­cus­sions on how to make improve­ments. This will help you to get buy-in to the improved process and greater own­er­ship from those who have to imple­ment it. 

How to Improve Your Per­for­mance Man­age­ment System

Here are five sug­gest­ed steps to improv­ing your per­for­mance man­age­ment processes:

  1. Sum­marise the results and areas for improve­ment into a pre­sen­ta­tion that can be eas­i­ly digest­ed by those out­side of HR.

  2. Con­sult senior man­age­ment on the results. Obtain their sup­port for mak­ing changes and seek their ideas for how to make improvements.

  3. Run focus groups with a vari­ety of man­agers and employ­ees from dif­fer­ent areas of the organ­i­sa­tion. Dis­cuss the results with them and ask for their sug­ges­tions for improvement.

  4. Decide on what actions should be tak­en to address the issues dis­cussed and draw up a pro­posed action plan. Dis­cuss this with your senior man­age­ment and manager/​employee focus groups to get their feedback.

  5. Make any required amend­ments to the action plan based on the feed­back received, then imple­ment the plan.

While involv­ing peo­ple in the redesign of your per­for­mance man­age­ment process­es is essen­tial, they prob­a­bly won’t be able to pro­vide all the answers. Some­times you’ll need to present them with options based upon best prac­tice from out­side of the organ­i­sa­tion. For this rea­son, you should make it a pri­or­i­ty to remain up-to-date with per­for­mance man­age­ment trends, know­ing that the field of HR is ever-evolving.

We have helped hun­dreds of organ­i­sa­tions improve their per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tems by mov­ing away from annu­al appraisals. We can help you improve con­ver­sa­tions and encour­age great per­for­mance in your organ­i­sa­tion. Get in touch today to dis­cuss how our per­for­mance man­age­ment soft­ware can help you.

Get started with our free version!

Begin your journey today at no cost. Loved by HR professionals and employees alike, become a part of our community of hundreds of thousands of users who depend on Clear Review to enhance both their performance and their teams. Join the Clear Review movement for free and achieve your highest potential.

Get Started