Clear Review has joined Advanced - Discover our full suite of powerful and innovative people management solutions

Find out more
Back to blog

Performance Management Methods to Manage Uncertain Employees

Nervous man looking how the interviewer is reading his resume during a job interview.

How can you inspire an indi­vid­ual to have faith in their abil­i­ties and excel?

Some employ­ees need more hand-hold­ing than oth­ers. As man­agers, we know how much time and atten­tion under­con­fi­dent employ­ees can require. They can be slow­er, over­ly cau­tious and seek clar­i­fi­ca­tion on many things. For a busy man­ag­er, this type of employ­ee can be a lot to handle.

But we should remem­ber that these uncer­tain employ­ees are actu­al­ly des­per­ate to do a good job. They just need time and reas­sur­ance — and in time, it will pay off. After all, employ­ees with greater faith in their abil­i­ty per­form far bet­ter than those who doubt themselves.

So how can you adapt your per­for­mance man­age­ment sys­tem to moti­vate, inspire and embold­en an uncer­tain employ­ee? Begin by fol­low­ing the steps below and you’ll begin to notice your employ­ee slow­ly devel­op­ing con­fi­dence and reas­sur­ance in their strengths.

Make it clear that you believe in their abilities

It should already be obvi­ous that you believe in your employ­ees. After all, if you didn’t think they could do their job, you cer­tain­ly wouldn’t have hired them. How­ev­er, some employ­ees are wor­ried they’ll let you down, or that per­haps their CV and inter­view­ing skills are more impres­sive than their work per­for­mance is. Some peo­ple even suf­fer from what is known as Imposter Syn­drome”. This is a con­cept that describes high-achiev­ing indi­vid­u­als who have a com­plete inabil­i­ty to inter­nalise their accom­plish­ments. They’re in con­stant fear that, one day, they will be out­ed as a fraud, despite what skills they may have.

Take the time to express that you have com­plete faith in their abil­i­ties and let them know that even if it takes them a while to become ful­ly pro­duc­tive, that’s okay. It’s bet­ter that they advance and a slow and steady pace than try to take too much on at once and suf­fer burnout.

Don’t micro­man­age your workforce

Your under­con­fi­dent employ­ee may be so because they have always been micro­man­aged in the past. When you have every aspect of your work­ing life man­dat­ed and direct­ed, you can’t branch out. You can’t exper­i­ment. You can’t devel­op the skills you want and you can’t become self-reliant. So although this might be some­thing your employ­ee is accus­tomed to, you don’t want to con­tin­ue the tradition.

Instead of con­stant­ly look­ing over your employee’s shoul­der and instruct­ing them, give them some auton­o­my. At Clear Review, we advise man­agers to let employ­ees write their own SMART objec­tives — although, of course, this should always be on the back of a dis­cus­sion with the man­ag­er. You might also con­sid­er allow­ing them to use some work time to work on a par­tic­u­lar project or to devel­op a giv­en skill. You might con­sid­er imple­ment­ing flex­i­ble work­ing, so they have con­trol over their hours. All of this will even­tu­al­ly con­tribute to a more inde­pen­dent, con­fi­dent mindset.

Remem­ber to deliv­er praise and recog­ni­tion in a time­ly manner

If an employ­ee is uncer­tain, what they are real­ly look­ing for is reas­sur­ance that they are doing the right thing, or advanc­ing at a healthy pace. If you’re tight-lipped with your praise and acknowl­edge­ments, this won’t help your employee’s lev­els of confidence.

We rec­om­mend you incor­po­rate con­tin­u­ous per­for­mance man­age­ment into your com­pa­ny. This means man­ag­er and employ­ee will have month­ly check-ins, and man­agers can use this time to deliv­er appro­pri­ate, hon­est recog­ni­tion and strengths-based feed­back. Remem­ber, recog­ni­tion is always more effec­tive when it is spe­cif­ic and timely.

Be open to their feed­back on exist­ing processes

What­ev­er you do, don’t make your under­con­fi­dent employ­ee feel super­flu­ous. Remind them they are an inte­gral ele­ment of the team and that their feed­back is always valued.

Are they hav­ing issues with cer­tain work­place process­es? Do they have ideas on how to improve cer­tain areas of the organ­i­sa­tion? Take all these thoughts on board. You nev­er know what valu­able feed­back might lead to sig­nif­i­cant boosts in over­all com­pa­ny pro­duc­tiv­i­ty. Your employee’s con­fi­dence will be ele­vat­ed not only by man­age­ment lis­ten­ing and enter­tain­ing their feed­back, but if they are able to see the pos­i­tive effects caused by their input, this can do won­ders for their ego.

Use per­for­mance man­age­ment soft­ware to pro­vide real-time communication

Let your employ­ee know that you are always avail­able for a dis­cus­sion, or to deliv­er feed­back, at any point. This might be the safe­ty net they need to get on with their work and per­form at a high stan­dard. Know­ing they have you on hand when required will be great for their peace of mind. Our per­for­mance review soft­ware allows every­one in the organ­i­sa­tion to exchange real-time, hon­est feed­back at the click of a but­ton. Don’t allow your­self to fall behind in terms of tech­no­log­i­cal advance­ment. With mil­len­ni­als (who expect instant feed­back) increas­ing­ly mak­ing up the work­force, real-time feed­back is increas­ing­ly crit­i­cal for busi­ness success.

Experience our hassle-free performance management software
Book a Live Demo

If you’d like to know Clear Review’s per­for­mance appraisal soft­ware can help you improve employ­ee engage­ment and boost com­pa­ny pro­duc­tiv­i­ty, book a demo here. We can also arrange a 15-minute free per­for­mance man­age­ment soft­ware con­sul­ta­tion at any time.